Send an answer to a topic: New categories for TV stuff
Warning, this subject is old (4422 days without answer)
G-MANN
Noticed these two programs got grouped in this category when they aren't non-fiction, but they still aren't a series:
http://www.imcdb.org/movie_138972-K-9-and-Company.html (pilot episode for a series that never got picked up)
http://www.imcdb.org/movie_252066-Triple-Scotch-and-Wry.html (listed as "video" on IMDB)
Oh well, instead of getting antp to create even more categories, I'll change K9 & Company to "Short Movie" (it must be about 30 mins or so) and with Triple Scotch and Wry, I looked it up and I can't tell whether it's a compilation video of sketches from the Scotch and Wry TV series and or a special video release with new material. This page http://www.allcelticmusic.com/music/62c92a84-f870-102a-8020-000f1f67beb1/Triple_Scotch_%26_Wry.html says it's 90 mins. For now I'll list it as "Movie Made for TV" (although it's direct-to-video)
http://www.imcdb.org/movie_138972-K-9-and-Company.html (pilot episode for a series that never got picked up)
http://www.imcdb.org/movie_252066-Triple-Scotch-and-Wry.html (listed as "video" on IMDB)
Oh well, instead of getting antp to create even more categories, I'll change K9 & Company to "Short Movie" (it must be about 30 mins or so) and with Triple Scotch and Wry, I looked it up and I can't tell whether it's a compilation video of sketches from the Scotch and Wry TV series and or a special video release with new material. This page http://www.allcelticmusic.com/music/62c92a84-f870-102a-8020-000f1f67beb1/Triple_Scotch_%26_Wry.html says it's 90 mins. For now I'll list it as "Movie Made for TV" (although it's direct-to-video)
antp
Better late than never, I renamed "TV Show" to "Non-fiction TV".
For the French version I kept "Show TV" as (to me) in French it describes well that category.
For the French version I kept "Show TV" as (to me) in French it describes well that category.
G-MANN
I was just talking about a category for things like the Clarkson DVDs, I'd still keep the direct-to-video movies listed as movies.
antp
and talk shows and reality are not allowed anyway.
But for the few that are on the site, we should have a distinct category
And there is not only Top Gear: we have several car shows like that.
Alan Partridge: Welcome to the Places of My Life
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2227372/ is listed as "TV" which is perfectly sufficient. You could just change "TV Show" to "TV".
As I said, I do not see the point of having one more category for rare cases like that: there is not real interest of having these listed separately.
Same for direct-to-video: can't these be considered as real movies? The production of these is not so different...
chicomarx
+1 for a Direct to Video category, which imdb also has - simply as "V".
I'm not sure about subdividing TV in too many categories. Why Non-Fiction TV when there's a documentary category? Top Gear is fine as "TV-Series" IMO, and talk shows and reality are not allowed anyway.
Alan Partridge: Welcome to the Places of My Life
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2227372/ is listed as "TV" which is perfectly sufficient. You could just change "TV Show" to "TV".
I'm not sure about subdividing TV in too many categories. Why Non-Fiction TV when there's a documentary category? Top Gear is fine as "TV-Series" IMO, and talk shows and reality are not allowed anyway.
Alan Partridge: Welcome to the Places of My Life
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2227372/ is listed as "TV" which is perfectly sufficient. You could just change "TV Show" to "TV".
G-MANN
Because it just doesn't make sense when there's no more than 1 episode. I can tell you don't want to bother making a category for TV Special so perhaps TV movie is the best compromise.
antp
Why not "mini series", even if there is no "episodes" ? As it is for short things series-like but with less episodes.
G-MANN
And what would we list something like that Alan Partridge program as? (which is a TV special and fiction)
By the way, last night I went through the list of TV series and changed some to "TV Show" (reality TV, documentary shows etc.). I've probably missed some, I just skimmed over the 21 page list and picked out ones that I recognised or could tell weren't fiction.
By the way, last night I went through the list of TV series and changed some to "TV Show" (reality TV, documentary shows etc.). I've probably missed some, I just skimmed over the 21 page list and picked out ones that I recognised or could tell weren't fiction.
antp
Indeed, unless someone comes with a better name, I think it will fit well.
owlman
^^ I like that idea, "Non-Fiction TV"
It fits for talk shows, reality shows, TV documentaries/news, and shows like Top Gear or Mythbusters.
It fits for talk shows, reality shows, TV documentaries/news, and shows like Top Gear or Mythbusters.