You know, that happens all the time, finding people that do not think like you, or have different tastes, or do things differently, etc.

The following is off-topic, but I think to it just right now:

It is like when chosing the best view of a car for its picture on the site. That's why we set a "rule" (that is not so well respected I think) that when the images are upgraded to better ones, the new one should be taken from the exact same scene and angle, except if there is a really better view.
For example, for some of my pictures that you replaced by better ones (from DVD) for some movies, I think that the picture that you selected is less good than the one that I selected. But I guess that if you replaced it, it is because you thought the opposite (hence that "rule" of keeping same scene/angle, to not have to ask which picture is the best)